Case study – Misleading question on an application form to join a professional body
We were recently contacted by an individual who had some concerns about the question relating to criminal convictions on the application form to join a professional body. The question asked:
‘I have been convicted of a criminal offence Yes / No’
The organisation stated that they would be carrying out a standard Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) check, however we didn’t believe that the question they were asking made it clear that applicants did not need to disclose ‘protected’ cautions or convictions.
We contacted the professional body to raise our concerns about the misleading question and explained that due to the way the question was worded, applicants could disclose more information than the professional body was legally entitled to know about.
As we received no response from the professional body we forwarded the matter to the Information Commissioners Office (ICO) as we felt that potentially, the professional body could be in breach of the Data Protection Act by processing and storing data unlawfully.
Several weeks later, we were contacted by the professional body who apologised for not responding to us. They informed us that they had amended their application form. It stated:
‘I have been convicted of a criminal offence Yes / No
Please note that you do not need to disclose protected convictions that are filtered from a standard or enhanced Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) check.’
We felt that the question was probably as clear and concise as it could be.
This case demonstrates how professional bodies often believe that the questions they are asking are very clear when in fact, due to changes in legislation, they can be quite misleading. This may result in applicants over disclosing and the professional body potentially breaching the Data Protection Act.
Notes about this case study
This case study relates to our work with other organisations.
Names and details have been changed to protect the identity of those involved.
- Blog - Government publishes summary of responses to call for evidence on the employment of people with convictions Posted on: Oct 17th, 2019
Last week, more than a year since the consultation closed, the…
- Autumn 2019 Newsletter - What we've been up to Posted on: Oct 4th, 2019
Today we've published our autumn 2019 newsletter. The newsletter…
- Just 3 places remaining for our criminal record disclosure training on 26th November - Book now! Posted on: Oct 2nd, 2019
Places are limited so please book early to avoid…
- Some examples of people we've helped Posted on: Sep 27th, 2019
Looking back over the last couple of months, we’ve written up a few…
- Monthly update - September 2019 Posted on: Sep 27th, 2019
We've just published our update for September 2019. This…